NIO vs Tesla stock: is now the time to buy these EV shares?

12 months-to-date, both NIO (NYSE: NIO) and Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) have underperformed the Nasdaq index. In truth, whilst the Nasdaq has fallen about 13%, Tesla has fallen nearly 15%, and NIO an even far more depressing 40%. But electric powered car or truck (EV) makers continue to be in need, and I feel that the current significant cost of oil will pace up the transition. As these kinds of, should I be buying Tesla inventory or NIO nowadays? 

NIO stock: unbelievable progress, but Chinese worries 

NIO has been able to improve revenues substantially more than the past few several years. In the current comprehensive-yr success, it noted revenues of around $5.6bn, a 122% improve calendar year-on-year. Deliveries of autos also achieved about 91,000, up in excess of 109% from the earlier year. These are unbelievable development figures and illustrate the extraordinary potential of the business. 

But there are symptoms that progress is setting up to sluggish. For illustration, complete revenues for the initially quarter of 2022 are anticipated to improve only close to 22%. Evidently, this progress is significantly slower than in excess of the past year and is a stress pattern. 

There are also concerns about the potential delisting of Chinese stocks in the US, which provides an extra chance to NIO not identified with Tesla inventory. This is mainly due to the tensions involving the two nations. But there have been signs not too long ago of guidance from China in the direction of US-listed stocks, signalling issues may perhaps transform. That usually means the delisting threat could recede. 

All round, I’m tempted to get started a modest speculative situation in NIO. When advancement has slowed lately, there is plenty of hope for the future, such as the launch of new automobiles and enlargement into Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden and Denmark. There is also hope that it may perhaps achieve profitability by 2024, which would be a major achievement. For these reasons, the existing dip appears a fantastic time for me to get. 

Tesla inventory: additional experienced but experiencing growth 

Tesla inventory has been much far more resilient than NIO above the previous several months. This might be due to the fact it has a demonstrated record of profitability. In 2021, revenues rose 71% yr-on-12 months to $53.8bn, and net cash flow totalled $5.5bn. Further, inspite of the semiconductor scarcity and source chain challenges, Tesla managed to develop 305,000 motor vehicles in the first quarter of 2022. These are exceptional numbers and exhibit the company’s prowess and competitive gain over other EV makers. 

But there are some dangers involved with Tesla. In individual, there is growing competitors in the sector. This includes new entrants to the marketplace, these as Rivian and Lucid Motors. Even further, Tesla inventory trades at a price-to-income ratio of more than 10, which is pretty significant, and undoubtedly increased than NIO. This suggests to me that long run accomplishment is presently priced in and there may be limited upside potential. For these reasons, I won’t be acquiring Tesla. In the NIO vs Tesla struggle, NIO wins out for me.