Better Acquire: Amazon vs. Etsy

E-commerce has been one of the defining traits of the very last ten years, and marketplaces like Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) and Etsy (NASDAQ:ETSY) have benefited enormously as gross sales have shifted on line. Not surprisingly, which is translated into big gains for buyers, with shares of Amazon and Etsy up 100% and 445%, respectively, in the final a few yrs.

Even so, the e-commerce revolution is much from around. According to eMarketer, just 18% of all retail profits occurred online in 2020, and that figure will only achieve 19.5% in 2021. That leaves a lot of home for these digital disruptors to develop. But which is the better obtain, Amazon or Etsy?

Table of Contents


Jeff Bezos launched Amazon with a mission: to establish the world’s most buyer-centric organization. To that finish, he helped pioneer e-commerce, bringing an at any time-growing searching knowledge to shoppers in the comfort and ease of their residences.

Woman sitting in front of a computer, crossing an item off a paper list.

Impression supply: Getty Photographs

So considerably, that method has labored very well. Right now Amazon is the second-premier retailer in the earth, and the main e-commerce platform in the United States by a large margin. But Bezos didn’t stop there.

To guidance its marketplace, Amazon designed a fulfillment and logistics community that rivals the scale of carriers like FedEx. This vertical integration helps streamline transport, command prices, and provide Prime customers with a single- or two-day supply on in excess of 100 million things.

Furthering the bull situation, Amazon World-wide-web Services (AWS) is the global leader in cloud computing, with 37% market place share, according to Canalys. Cloud providers revenue will come with a significantly larger running margin than retail income, permitting the firm to fund the advancement of its e-commerce business in a way that most competition can’t match.

As a full, Amazon’s fiscal effectiveness has been stellar in current a long time.



Q1 2021 (TTM)



$177.9 billion

$419.1 billion


Free of charge Cash Circulation

$6.4 billion

$21.8 billion


Facts resource: Amazon SEC filings. TTM = trailing-12-months. CAGR = compound annual advancement charges.

Going ahead, Amazon really should profit as e-commerce and cloud computing become increasingly popular. Additionally, the company’s speedy development positions it for further industry share gains in both of those industries. From that viewpoint, irrespective of a $1.6 trillion marketplace cap, this stock nevertheless appears to be like a sector-beating investment.


Etsy operates a global market for handcrafted and specialised goods. Its platform connects imaginative sellers with prospective buyers searching for unique goods. In actuality, in a 2020 study, 88% of buyers indicated that Etsy sells products and solutions they are unable to locate anyplace else. Anecdotally, I have had a very similar encounter as an Etsy shopper myself.

Ive-covered brick exterior of rustic Etsy office building.

Image resource: Etsy

Contrary to Amazon, Etsy isn’t going to contend in opposition to its sellers. As a substitute, the company generates revenue by means of market fees (i.e. listings, transactions, and payment processing), as properly as costs for optional providers like on-site adverts and discounted shipping labels. This greater aligns the enterprise with its sellers — in other words and phrases, Etsy succeeds when its sellers triumph.

To that finish, Etsy presents enterprises with a dashboard to track orders, deal with stock, and draw insights about their effectiveness. This resource also lets Etsy sellers to interact with buyers, which can support construct lasting client relationships. Again, this differs from Amazon’s tactic.

Very last 12 months, the pandemic-pushed shift to electronic commerce driven a document economical performance. Active sellers amplified 62% to 4.4 million, and energetic purchasers jumped 77% to 81.9 million. As consequence, Etsy’s gross merchandise product sales (GMS) surged 107% to $10.2 billion — a meaningful acceleration from 27% growth in 2019.

Furthermore, Etsy managed that momentum in the 1st quarter of 2021 as GMS growth accelerated further more to 132%, driving earnings of $551 million. For context, Etsy generated additional earnings in Q1 2021 than it did during the entirety of 2017.



2021 Q1 (TTM)



$441.2 million

$2. billion


Absolutely free Cash Flow

$55.9 million

$787.8 million


Data supply: Etsy SEC filings. TTM = trailing-12-months. CAGR = compound annual progress fee.

Etsy has quietly develop into a substantial participant in e-commerce it is really the fourth-most frequented market in the U.S., and the eighth-most visited marketplace in Canada. But administration sees increased accomplishment on the horizon, and expects the firm’s industry prospect to reach $437 billion by 2023, up from $249 billion in 2019.

Notably, Etsy is developing noticeably faster than its current market option, an sign that it is really getting industry share. Which is why the foreseeable future appears to be bright for this electronic retailer.

The verdict

I like the two of these companies and I am an Amazon shareholder, but I consider Etsy is the better obtain listed here. Its focus on special and frequently customized inventory has differentiated it from other marketplaces. And the organization confirmed its mettle in the course of the coronavirus, mounting to the situation when individuals wanted deal with masks, whilst still managing to develop at an incredible tempo.

Even though Etsy certainly serves a niche market place, the business added benefits from a sizable current market opportunity, robust management, and a growth system that is been quite effective so far. 

This short article represents the feeling of the author, who may possibly disagree with the “official” advice place of a Motley Idiot high quality advisory company. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even a single of our have — will help us all imagine critically about investing and make decisions that aid us develop into smarter, happier, and richer.